Monday, March 7, 2016

Restoration versus Stabilization in Charleston, South Carolina

When I travelled to Charleston with a group of fellow graduate students I expected to learn more about the history of the city. I anticipated visiting plantations to learn more about the economy of Charleston. I expected to see many fine examples of beautiful church architecture as an expression of a relationship to God. I hoped to be immersed Charleston long and rich history while exploring the uniquely eclectic downtown area. I expected to learn about Charleston's military importance through a visit to Fort Moultrie. What I did not expect was to be introduced to two very different techniques of preserving historical sites. Drayton Hall and Middleton Place are representative of these two techniques.

Middleton Place is an excellent example of a restoration site. The theory behind restoration sites is to return a historic site to how it appeared during a specific time period. For example, Middleton Place housed a successful and influential family during the colonial and post revolutionary era. The current property reflects the architecture, layout and décor of that time period.  While many pieces inside the house are originals, the majority of the inside décor was made to resemble what the house looked like in the colonial era. The house that serves as a museum was not the manor house on the property. The original manor house and flank houses were destroyed during the Civil War and subsequent earthquake. The current house was one of the flank houses, which was reconstructed after the war. Click the following link to view a video about restoration in the gardens at Middleton Place. 

In the gardens stands a testament to Middleton Place's ability to persevere. This statue has survived wars, earthquakes, and many hurricanes. 
Drayton Hall, however, represents a stabilization site. When the National Trust took over care of Drayton Hall in 1974, they decided to focus on preserving the current condition of the estate rather than restoring it to its colonial condition. Therefore, Drayton Hall’s interior is not as visually appealing as all of the décor and artifacts have been removed. The house contains no heating or cooling system and no electricity, which means artifacts cannot be kept on site. Tourists are only allowed in certain parts of the house to keep the flooring and walls intact. Any work done on the property is to keep the structure stable rather than for restoration. The floors, walls, and stonework are original.  However, the paint inside the house was added much later and detracts from the historical value of the house.




These pictures demonstrate the very well preserved exterior of Drayton Hall. The work that can be seen is an ongoing project on the columns of the house. The purpose of this project is to stabilize the structure of the house rather than restore the exterior to a particular time period. 

These columns, stored in the basement. are believed to be the original columns of the house. 
This is what remains of one of the fireplaces in Drayton Hall. Vandals stole the mantle from this fireplace. Since Drayton Hall is a stabilization site, this mantle has not been replaced. 
The ceiling in the large first floor room of Drayton Hall. Under stabilization, the caretakers of the property will work to keep this architectural piece in its present condition. 
Tour guides alternate which stair case use to bring tourists up and down. When walking downstairs, the body exerts more force causing more wear to the staircase. By alternating the route to take tourists the tour guides are able to even out the stress on the two staircases. This method is one of the many stabilization techniques used at Drayton Hall.

The choice to either stabilize or restore a historic site may depend on the condition of the property. The structures of Middleton place suffered war, hurricanes, and earthquakes. Middleton Place could not be preserved, as the structures were destroyed. Drayton Hall fortunately escaped this fate and therefore was a better candidate for stabilization as the original building remained in tact. Both methods are impressive. From a tourism perspective, Middleton place has more to offer because it takes visitors back in time. It even serves as working rice plantation.  Drayton Hall’s merit lies in its significance as a very well persevered site rather than for its tourism appeal.



Monday, March 17, 2014

Versailles: The Quintessential European Palace

Prior to 1662, the French royal family used Versailles merely as a hunting retreat. Louis XIII built a simple chateau able to accommodate himself and a small entourage. The surrounding area of Versailles was nothing more than a small country village. It was not until the reign of Louis XIV that Versailles became the quintessential European palace that other monarchs longed for.  Louis XIV disliked and distrusted Paris. Louis XIV desired to create a lavish residential community for himself and the French government. With the government housed in one area, the Sun King could exert complete control over a centralized government.Therefore, he moved the French government from Paris to Versailles in 1682. The Sun King needed a residence befitting his grandeur. The chateau de Versailles still stands today, as a reflection of the grand empire of Lois XIV.

                                             the face of Louis XIV as the Sun King as a gold medallion
The symbol of the Louis XIV, the Sun King

Most of the construction of the gardens and the grounds occurred between 1668 and 1684. Louis XIV constructed Versailles through four building campaigns. Besides the Sun King, three men were mostly responsible for the design of the palace. Louis Le Vau served as the main architect on the project. Charles Le Brun designed the interior of the seven hundred-room palace. Andre Le Notre designed the lavish landscaping around the palace.

                                        A vase featuring a satyr or the god Pan
A timeline from the literature given to visitors of Versailles.

Louis Le Vau designed the palace of Versailles using French Baroque style of architecture. French Baroque architecture inserts grand details upon orderly, symmetrical buildings. Large curved forms, twisted columns, high domes, and other complicated shapes characterize this type of architecture.  The exterior is reminiscent of classical Greek and Roman designs.












The interior of the palace of Versailles equals the grandeur of the architecture. Charles Le Brun created the Louis XIV style, which includes red and gold brocaded fabrics, marbling and many other lavish interior details.  The best example of this style and Brun’s most famous room is the Hall of Mirrors. This main gallery of the palace features seventeen mirrored arches reflecting seventeen arcaded windows, each looking out to the gardens. To emphasize the power of the French monarch, Louis the XIV commissioned Brun to paint the splendors of French government on the ceiling. Louis the XIV is depicted as a Roman Emperor, a great ruler over many foreign kingdoms.

                                         La Galerie des Glaces, the Hall of Mirrors
The Hall of Mirrors

The gardens surrounding the palace are some of the most famous pieces of landscaping in history. The garden at the Versailles palace is Europe’s largest palace garden covering 250 acres of land. Andre Le Notre designed a series of geometric paths, bushes, trees, and flowerbeds with many statues adorning the gardens. Louis XIV insisted on created impressive water displays throughout the gardens. Andre Le Norte executed this vision through the construction of several fountains. The Fountain of Apollo and the Latonia Basin were not only artistic masterpieces but for their time were technological advanced hydraulic masterpieces. These fountains could not be supplied with enough water to run for more than special occasions. 

                                                           Geometric Gardens in Versailles
                                 

The highlight of the garden is the Grande Canal. It measures 1500 meters long by 62 meters wide. Louis XIV sought to recreate the canals of Venice by bringing in gondolas and gondoliers. The “little Venice” housed these imports and yachts. The Grande canal also served as a holding tank for the water drained from the fountains to later be used to water the gardens.

                                


Unfortunately, during the revolution the temporary government auctioned off many of the pieces of artwork and furniture. The French government did not seriously seek to regain these pieces until World War II.  The palace of Versailles is not only famous for its architectural and artistic beauty.  Versailles witnessed several key historic events, including the Treaty of Paris - ending the American Revolution, proclamation of Kaiser Wilhelm I as Emperor of Germany, and the Treaty of Versailles - ending WWI.

For More Information

“1682 Versailles, capital of the kingdom.” Chateau De Versailles. http://en.chateauversailles.fr/history/the-great-days/most-important-dates/1682-versailles-capital-of-the-kingdom (accessed on March 14, 2014).


“Château de Versailles, France.” World Site Guides.com. http://www.worldsiteguides.com/europe/france/chateau-de-versailles/ (accessed on March 14, 2014).

Jarus, Owen. “Palace of Versailles: Facts and History.” Live Science. http://www.livescience.com/38903-palace-of-versailles-facts-history.html (accessed on March 14, 2014).

“Palace of Versailles and its Gardens.” Irvine Valley College. http://www.ivc.edu/academics/schoolFA/arthistory/Documents/VERSAILLES_Fall_05/architecture.html (accessed on March 13, 2014).

“Versailles.” Historylines. http://www.historylines.net/history/17th_cent/versailles.html (accessed on March 14, 2014).

“Versailles Palace: Chateau de Versailles.” A View on Cities.  http://www.aviewoncities.com/paris/versailles.htm (accessed on March 14, 2014).

Monday, February 24, 2014

Adolf Hitler: Rise to Power

Can one man really start an entire world war? It is fair to argue that Adolf Hitler’s pursuit of land for his ethnically clean Aryan race caused World War II.  There are many more factors to consider besides the ambitions of Hitler. Would Hitler have been able to rise to power if Germany was not suffering under the crushing weight of WWI reparations and the Depression? Hitler may not have been the sole cause of WWII. And Hitler may have been as successful if conditions in Germany had not been so dismal. What is certain is that Hitler was a major player in WWII and will be remembered forever.

Early Life

On April 20, 1889, Klara Polzl bore Alois Hitler his fourth of sixth children, Adolf; in Branau am Inn, Austria.  When Adolf was three, his family moved from Austria to Germany. Hitler experienced tragedy early in life when his younger brother Edmund died in 1900.  Three years later, his father died suddenly. While his father, a customs official, maintained a cold and strict relationship with Hitler, his death undoubtedly affected the thirteen year old. Hitler found formal education boring. He only enjoyed his history studies, which focused on instilling a strong sense of German nationalism in students. Hitler’s caring and loving mother allowed the sixteen-year-old Hitler to drop out of school to pursue an art career in Vienna.  Like his education, Hitler’s art career was unsuccessful. In 1907, Hitler failed the entrance exam for the Vienna Academy of Art. Tragedy struck the young man’s life once again, as breast cancer overcame his dear mother. A few months later, Hitler attempted to reapply for the Vienna art school but was rejected again. While earning a pittance from selling postcards and architectural drawings, Hitler lived in homeless shelters and men’s hostels. While in Vienna, Hitler actively participated in the local political environment. His struggle in Vienna shaped many of his now memorable political ideas.

                                              Photograph showing Adolf Hitler at school
Hitler as a child: top middle

Military Career

Hitler’s military career experienced far greater success than his educational or art career. In 1913, Hitler left Vienna to avoid military service under the Hapsburg Empire. While living in Munich, Europe erupted into World War. Hitler quickly volunteered to serve in a Bavarian regiment. By December of 1914, Hitler became a decorated soldier, earning the Iron Cross for bravery. In October 1916, a grenade splinter temporarily wounded him. In August of 1918, Hitler won the Iron Cross again, but this time with the first class designation. While recovering from a gas attack that caused him temporary blindness, Hitler heard the devastating news that Germany had been defeated.

                                                   Portrait of Adolf Hitler 

Rise to Power


Hitler believed that Marxist leaders had betrayed Germany. The treaty of Versailles called for the demilitarization of Germany and the reparations assigning blame to Germany. These stipulations enraged Hitler. In 1919, he joined the German’s Workers’ Party (DAP). While with this organization Hitler became known for his vitriolic speeches, in which he spread his anti Socialist and anti- Semitic views. Hitler used his leadership position to lead a failed coup against the German government in November 1923. While serving time in prison for his crime, Hitler wrote the now famous Mein Kampf. The Great Depression gave Hitler the advantage he needed to further his political career. In 1932, he lost the race for German presidency to Paul von Hindenburg. Hindenburg, however, appointed Hitler to chancellor. Following the death of Hindenburg, Hitler assumed the role of both president and chancellor. He used his political status to spread his ideas and build up an army. In August of 1939, Hitler and the German forces invaded Poland and began World War II.

For More Information:

"Adolf Hitler." The Biography Channel website. http://www.biography.com/people/adolf-hitler-9340144 (accessed February 24, 2014).

“Adolf Hitler.” The History Channel website. http://www.history.com/topics/world-war-ii/adolf-hitler (accessed on February 22, 2014).

“More Information about Adolf Hitler.” History: BBC.com. http://www.bbc.co.uk/history/people/adolf_hitler#p00bhf0v (accessed on February 23, 2014).

Noakes, Jeremy. “The Rise of Adolf Hitler. “ History: BBC.com. Updated on March 30, 2012. http://www.bbc.co.uk/history/worldwars/wwtwo/hitler_01.shtml (accessed on February 23, 2014). 

Rosenburg, Jennifer. “Adolf Hitler.” 20th Century History: About.com. http://history1900s.about.com/cs/hitleradolf/p/hitler.htm (accessed February 22, 2014).